Monday, June 23, 2014

Egypt, Sudan part ways over boycott of the Nile Treaty

Khartoum ends two-year boycott of co-operation with the Nile Basin Initiative while Tanzania unexpectedly urges review of Entebbe Agreement to accommodate Cairo. TEA Graphic

Khartoum ends two-year boycott of co-operation with the Nile Basin Initiative while Tanzania unexpectedly urges review of Entebbe Agreement to accommodate Cairo. TEA Graphic 
By JOINT REPORT The EastAfrican
In Summary
  • Egypt remains defiant, with its observer to the meeting reading a statement saying Egypt was not in a position “to consider that the signed draft Co-operative Framework Agreement(CFA) is an NBI outcome.”
  • Both Sudan and Egypt froze their participation in the NBI to protest the 2010 CFA, which upstream countries drafted to replace a 1959 colonial era agreement that gave Egypt and Sudan absolute control over use of the Nile’s waters.
  • Khartoum’s defection now leaves the DR Congo as Egypt’s only ally, since South Sudan is expected to accede to the CFA in the near future.

Sudan has broken ranks with Egypt in their joint opposition to a new agreement with Nile Basin countries for sharing of the Nile waters.

Tanzania has also changed its mind about the new Nile Treaty and is now calling for further dialogue among all riparian countries to accommodate the concerns raised by Egypt.
At the 22nd Nile Basin Council of Ministers meeting in Khartoum last week, Sudan officially ended its two-year boycott of co-operation under the Nile Basin Initiative (NBI), paying off its arrears to the organisation and calling on Egypt to follow suit.
“I would like to place an appeal to our sister nation. Egypt, your seat is still empty. Your resumption of activities will further consolidate our gains and integrity in the region,” Sudanese Minister for Water Resources and Electricity Mutaz Musa Abdalla said in his opening remarks on June 19.
But Egypt remains defiant, with its observer to the meeting reading a statement on behalf of Egyptian Minister for Water Resources and Irrigation Dr Hossam Moghazi saying Egypt was not in a position “to consider that the signed draft Co-operative Framework Agreement(CFA) is an NBI outcome.”
But Ethiopia, which championed the CFA, says while the future of NBI member countries was tied to the sustainable use of common resources, that will depend on “the presence of genuine co-operation, agreed upon legal frameworks and operational institutional arrangements that can regulate the equitable and reasonable utilisation of the resource.”
Both Sudan and Egypt froze their participation in the NBI to protest the 2010 CFA, which upstream countries drafted to replace a 1959 colonial era agreement that gave Egypt and Sudan absolute control over use of the Nile’s waters.
But Sudan now says though consensus is yet to be reached on “some political track issues, there is room to finalise the remaining differences in the near future.”
Khartoum’s defection now leaves the DR Congo as Egypt’s only ally, since South Sudan is expected to accede to the CFA in the near future.
Tanzania’s move has surprised the Nile Basin countries given that together with Kenya and Ethiopia, it was the pioneer in pushing for other riparian states to increase their shares of Nile water and were the first to sign the new treaty in 2010.
Tanzania’s stand
Tanzanian Minister for Foreign Affairs and International Co-operation Bernard Membe — who first put forward the suggestion — maintained in an interview with The EastAfrican that the agreement should be reviewed as a way of avoiding the possible conflicts among states.
He gave the example of the ongoing dispute between Egypt and Ethiopia over the $4.2 billion Grand Renaissance Dam, in addition to the fact that out of the seven countries that are signatories to the treaty, only Ethiopia and Tanzania have ratified it.

No comments :

Post a Comment