Saturday, November 30, 2013

Parliament must edit TJRC report to remove glaring shortcomings

MPs in the House during a past session.  Photo|FILE

MPs in the House during a past session. Photo|FILE  NATION MEDIA GROUP
By Kwamchetsi Makokha
More by this Author
Six months after the Truth, Justice and Reconciliation Commission handed in its final report, at the deadline for establishing its implementation mechanisms, its shortcomings are glaring.

The National Assembly, which was supposed to ensure the report’s implementation, can no longer hide its problems behind civility. Pressed by the expiry of various deadlines in the TJRC report, Members of Parliament have no choice but to square up to its embarrassing mistakes.
It has been forced to confront the obvious shoddiness in carelessly requiring the investigation of important members of society.

Even after the Kenyan commissioners — acting patriotically without the influence of foreign masters — took charge of the land chapter and omitted four odious paragraphs from the report, there are numerous shortcomings that require the intervention of sages in the National Assembly.
It is odious for the report to impute that the President, Deputy President, MPs and other leaders should be investigated for gross human rights violations, land grabbing, torture, massacre and what-not.

Having been popularly chosen in democratic elections, the leaders whose reputations are being unfairly impugned are obviously beyond reproach or suspicion. It is unconscionable to recommend further investigations — let alone prosecutions — when these leaders have been cleared outright at the ballot.

Asking the President to publicly apologise for gross injustices and human rights violations committed while he was still in his napkins would itself be a gross violation of his human rights.

People who died to preserve the national interest, those who lost limbs in the pursuit of national security, and others whose bodies were sexually invaded as a contribution to nation building cannot be the responsibility of the President. Many of the people who are assumed to have been assassinated were political suicides.

It would greatly demoralise the Kenya Defence Forces, Kenya Police Service and National Intelligence Service to be made to apologise for performing their official duties. The requirement of an apology for extra-judicial killings, detention, torture and sexual violence would take the glamour away from the security services and discourage young people from joining up.

Nothing could be achieved by the Judiciary apologising for judgments given by judicial officers who have since died, been purged or vetted out.

A slew of apologies without regard to the dignity of the offices that perform functions of state would injure the national interest irreparably. The TJRC report is the product of irresponsible posturing by civil society on the payroll of foreign powers jealous of Kenya’s rapid development.
There is no point in taking the country’s owners of capital, captains of industry and local investors in land to task for creating wealth when opportunity presented itself.

The people who tilled the land when it was all bush, the people who rescued money from the carelessness of public servants deserve recognition rather than unwarranted accusations.

That is why the National Assembly should seize the TJRC report and edit it for accuracy, consistency and truth. It should also ensure that the final product preserves the reputations of the innocent.
Although the initial intent of the law establishing the TJRC was to ensure that its report would be automatically implemented, the slipshod manner in which it has dealt with important people’s reputations calls for revisions.

Considering that there are many innocent people in the National Assembly who have been unfairly mentioned in the report, the august House is the best place to repair the damage caused and finally give Kenyans a report that is truthful, just and conciliatory.

No comments :

Post a Comment