‘Bosses had $10m in loans as Nakumatt sunk’

It will be doubly harder to recover any of the insider loans now that Nakumatt is completely shut down. PHOTO | FILE | NATION MEDIA GROUP 

In Summary

• The loans to the company’s directors are among a series of related party transactions amounting to $28 million, which are unlikely to be recovered.
• The report paints a picture of relatively loose governance at Nakumatt relative to other firms such as banks where insider dealings are more closely regulated

By BUSINESS DAILY
More by this Author

Nakumatt Holdings had lent its directors more than Ksh1 billion ($10 million) in interest-free soft loans by the time it was placed under administration on January 22, 2018, according to a review of the company’s financial statements.

The related party transactions were recently disclosed in a report for the year ended February 2018 by Parker Randall Eastern Africa, the retailer’s independent auditor.

The auditor did not specify which individuals owe the company money, underlining the weak governance in the board of the former giant retail chain that owes banks, landlords and suppliers as much as Ksh20 billion ($200 million).

Nakumatt’s founder and former chief executive Atul Shah was one of the two individuals listed as directors of the company as of the report date.

The amounts owed by insiders, which did not attract interest charges, had dropped to Ksh948 million ($9.48 million) as of February 2018, the period for which the latest financial records are available.

“Significant in this net balance is Ksh948 million ($9.48 million) due from the directors. These receivables are not supportable based on the available evidence,” says the report.

“The amounts due from a director are interest-free. They relate to short-term advances through a current account.”

The loans to the company’s directors are among a series of related party transactions amounting to Ksh2.8 billion ($28 million), which are unlikely to be recovered.

Others include amounts claimed from subsidiaries in Uganda, Rwanda and Tanzania, which ceased operations.

The administrator has written off Ksh1.5 billion ($15 million) or 53 per cent of the receivables, leaving a balance of Ksh1.3 billion ($13 million).

“There are no repayment plans for these balances; the companies frequently lend and borrow funds from each other,” the auditor said.

The report paints a picture of relatively loose governance at Nakumatt relative to other firms such as banks where insider dealings are more closely regulated.

There is a limit on the size of loans directors and employees of a bank can take in aggregate. The loans also typically attract interest charges, though sometimes at below market rates.

Revelations of Nakumatt’s insider loans come at a time when the retailer is closing most of its remaining branches, making compensation for creditors even less likely.

Mr Shah faces investigations over the loss of Ksh18 billion ($180 million) worth of stock.

Nakumatt administrator Peter Kahi said a forensic investigator will probe why Mr Shah wrote off stock worth Ksh18 billion ($180 million) in May 2018, before the company ground to a halt.

The High Court granted Nakumatt Supermarkets protection from its creditors, allowing the retailer to go into voluntary administration. The company sought protection using Kenya’s newly enacted company laws, which provide a path for distressed firms to avoid complete collapse.

At its height, the company, which began life as Nakuru Mattresses, had more than 60 outlets across Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania and Rwanda.

But its financial problems led to empty shelves and store closures, opening the way for foreign retailers like Carrefour and local rival, Naivas, to take over space it vacated.